Make-or-Buy Analysis: Should You Buy Equipment or Keep Outsourcing?
Consider an illustrative manufacturer paying $396,000 a year to outsource a finishing process. Equipment that could bring the work in-house would require a $240,000 investment, including installation and training. The purchase looks promising, but the supplier bill includes work the company would still have to perform. A make-or-buy analysis tests whether the expected savings justify that investment. For owners evaluating the proposal, fractional CFO services can help connect the production assumptions with the financial commitment. Here, “make” means performing the process internally; “buy” means continuing to purchase the service. The equipment purchase makes the internal option possible. It does not eliminate the cost of doing the work. The Initial Calculation Looks Attractive The manufacturer sends 18,000 components a year to its supplier, paying $22 for each accepted component. That rate includes associated transport and inspection. Its internal estimate is $14 per accepted...